← Back to Blog

October 21, 2026 · Violet Boutique Editorial

How We Choose Lube: What We Won't Sell and Why

Lube is the one product that goes inside you and stays there, so it's worth being fussier about than almost anything else we sell. A while ago we went back through every lube in the shop and asked a simple question: would we be comfortable recommending this to a friend? Roughly a third of them didn't make it. This is what we looked at, and just as importantly, what we couldn't check.

First: is anyone actually happy with it?

Before ingredients, we looked at the reviews. For each brand we found its best-known lube and checked how buyers rate it on Amazon.ca. If that flagship product was under 4 stars, or we couldn't find any real reviews for the brand at all, we took the brand's lubes off the shelf. A few unfamiliar names went this way, along with some brands that mostly sell other things and add a lube on the side. We'd rather stock fewer lubes that people clearly like. Our standards page explains how we use ratings across the shop.

What we took off the shelf because of the ingredients

Then we read the ingredient lists we had. We removed any lube that listed one of these:

Petroleum or mineral oil. These are the main ingredient in some creams and balms. They can weaken latex condoms and are hard to wash out, which makes them a poor choice for anything internal.

Numbing or desensitizing agents, such as benzocaine and lidocaine. Pain is how your body tells you something's wrong, and a lube that turns the volume down on it can hide the damage.

Parabens, named in the ingredients as methylparaben, propylparaben and so on. They're a preservative, and the evidence on them is genuinely debated, but there are plenty of lubes that do the same job without them, so we chose to skip them.

Warming, cooling and tingling agents, like menthol, cinnamon and capsaicin. They work by irritating tissue a little. That feels like a feature to some people and a bad afternoon to others, and the lining inside you is more sensitive than the skin on your hands.

Both glycerin and propylene glycol in the same bottle. Neither is alarming on its own, and we still stock lubes that contain one of them. Together they can make a lube very concentrated, which draws water out of the cells it touches. The World Health Organization's advice is to look for lubes under roughly 380 mOsm/kg, but almost no brand publishes that number, so we use the two-ingredient combination as the warning sign.

What we can't tell you

We're a small shop, not a lab. We go by the ingredient lists in our product information, and not every product has one. If a lube doesn't list its ingredients, we can't confirm that it's free of anything, and we won't pretend we can. A lube with parabens that never mention them in its description could still be on our shelf.

We also haven't tested anything ourselves, and none of this is medical advice. If you're prone to yeast infections or bacterial vaginosis, or you have allergies or sensitive skin, talk to a doctor or pharmacist. Everyone's body is different, and a lube we've left in is not a promise it's right for you.

What this means when you shop

You'll find fewer lubes here than at most shops, and nothing with a numbing agent, a petroleum base, parabens or a warming tingle. Water-based lubes work with everything, so they're the easiest place to start; our water-based category is a good first stop, and our lube basics guide covers when silicone is worth it. If you want flavour, the flavoured lubes that remain passed the same checks.

If you spot something here that doesn't live up to this, we'd like to know. You can reach us at the address on our standards page, and if you're right, we'll take it off the shelf.